Question: Saab 9-5 vs Merc E350

Sometimes I feel like I’m an alien.

RedJ wrote yesterday about a road test comparing the Saab 9-5 and the Mercedes E Class.

I clicked on the test and I read through some of it before thinking to myself “Why am I bothering with this one?”

Further to that, I have to ask myself Why did Auto Express bother with it? I know that the readers of automotive magazines like these tests. I guess that’s why.

How the 9-5 compares to the E Class is slightly interesting on an intellectual level but is completely irrelevant on an emotional level because I’ve got absolutely zero interest in any model from Mercedes Benz. None whatsoever.

And I don’t know of many people here who have talked about Mercedes, either.

But why confine it to Mercedes?

Maybe I’m just a complete sucker, but I have no serious interest in anything non-Saaby with the specific exceptions of a few models from Alfa Romeo and Porsche (and those aren’t models that compete with anything from Saab, they’re just things in specific niches that I’d like to own one day).

When people talk about this-model-from-Audi, that-model-from-BMW or this-model-from-whoever, I find myself wondering why. I have to ask myself OK, it’s probably a good car – but would you want to own it? It’s one thing to go through some quasi-intellectual exercise comparing what are essentially meaningless numbers on paper, but would you want to own it?

Maybe I just enjoy these cars too much. And I’ll be the first to admit that I do. I love the cars and I love the company. I love the little town they’re built in. I love the history behind the company and I really love the idea of them proving themselves in the future. A company with the qualities of Saab – as long as they’re preserved and persist into the future – deserves a place in the automotive landscape.

I know the Mercedes E Class is a good car. A great car, in fact. I’ve always had a very healthy respect for Mercedes Benz.

But owning one?

I could barely imagine anything less interesting. I’m an alien. I want the Saab.

——

Question

What other brands do you seriously – not just in arguments or intellectual exercises – but seriously consider buying as an alternative to Saab?

Henke
Guest
Henke
5 years 8 months ago

I must agree with you the only option for me is Alfa Romeo. But that day will probably never come! Im thinking of getting a SAAB tattoo of the logo 🙂

Amaranthen
Guest
Amaranthen
5 years 8 months ago

A Tatra T87 – any day in the week.

TurboLover
Guest
TurboLover
5 years 8 months ago

Haha,
50% Saab 92 + 50% Tucker Torpedo = Tatra T87
i.e. you still want half a Saab 🙂

Adrian
Guest
Adrian
5 years 8 months ago
At least I’ve only ever had a serious hankering for a T603. Very serious. Nearly bought one once… But – Swade – the point is that “we’re Saabies”. The vast majority of Saab buyers are not. They want a car of a particular size and type and price. A 9-5 or 9-3 happens to fit that bill – but so does an E/5/A6/whatever or C/3/A4/whatever. THAT’s why journos do comparisons. Not to preach to the choir, but to help “real buyers” make their minds up about which is the best car in any particular segment. Do they actually achieve anything?… Read more »
joszko
Guest
5 years 8 months ago

At this moment in time and space if I wouldn’t own a Saab I would be considering buying a BMW.

As for E-Class, I think I’m to young to own a Mercedes 😉

Palandi
Guest
Palandi
5 years 8 months ago

Swade,

maybe I’m a loner, but I serious consider having a MB as an alternative to Saab.

ok, I do live in Brazil and Saab was never sold here, but I will be divided when it enters the market, which is likely to happen in the near future. I’ll have to choose between a new 9-3 hatchback and the recently released Mercedes-Benz C-Class Coupe – even if the Saab comes only with four doors. and I’ll be certainly divided.

on the flipside, no other German brand turns me on, nor does Volvo.

saab93f
Guest
saab93f
5 years 8 months ago

For me Merc would be the only alternative (as we already have one). Audi is too boring, BMW ostentatious and Ovlov just wrong. I mean I possibly could live with owning a nice Beemer or Audi but Volvo….it just wont do.

Troels, Denmark
Guest
5 years 8 months ago

Emotionally: Alfa and Saab
Seriously, as you ask: None, but Saab..

Talladegan
Guest
Talladegan
5 years 8 months ago

I guess Alfa Romea, certain Citroens and Subaru in some ways…not much else really 🙂

Talladegan
Guest
Talladegan
5 years 8 months ago

I guess Alfa Romeo, certain Citroens and Subaru in some ways…not much else really 🙂

Anonymoose
Guest
Anonymoose
5 years 8 months ago

Saab only

Mikaik
Guest
Mikaik
5 years 8 months ago

Jaguar XF/XJ as main/single car.
Renault Megane RS for a “fun” car. Twingo GT for a commuting car (either that or Abarth 500). 🙂

I truly hope Saab will launch a small car though…

benrp
Guest
benrp
5 years 8 months ago

Jaguar and perhaps a Mini if I wanted a small car.

TurboLover
Guest
TurboLover
5 years 8 months ago

Not really anything else but Saab, but maybe Subaru or Porche as second car.

A bit OT. It is to bad that we Saab nuts aint enough in numbers to cover 120K Saab sales a year. I guess most Saab buyers are no real Saab nuts, but do consider Merc, Bimmer, Awdee, Ovlov et al. as well. That is why things like CO2 and the likes will matter for the survival of our favourite company

SaabAero
Guest
SaabAero
5 years 8 months ago

Next to a Saab that would be Volvo..

Andy Rupert
Guest
5 years 8 months ago

I’ve worked for a Volvo and Mercedes-Benz dealership for almost 3 years now. Realistically, I would choose a used Volvo — maybe an older V70 or an S60 and hopefully a C30 when the kids are grown. 🙂

baas900i
Guest
baas900i
5 years 8 months ago

Hilux D4D because its pretty empty in the outback and they keep going…..

till72
Guest
till72
5 years 8 months ago

As long as I can buy a Saab there is no alternative.

We had a Subaru, which was not a bad car at all, but it did just not feel right. It had no soul.

till72
Guest
till72
5 years 8 months ago

So I just realized that I am an alien, too. 😉

74stingray
Guest
74stingray
5 years 8 months ago

If not a Saab…. maybe a Audi.. maybe a Buick….

Jeff
Guest
Jeff
5 years 8 months ago

If I absolutely couldn’t have a Saab, I’d want a Buick, too.

I wonder if we’re the only two people on this site who feel that way.

Andy Rupert
Guest
5 years 8 months ago

Our dealership used to have a Buick franchise, but the cars never grew on me. What is is that you like about Buick?

TurboHeart
Guest
TurboHeart
5 years 8 months ago

If there were no other option, than buying a SAAB, I think I’d consider a Subaru outback. It’s a decent car with a good engine and 4×4. Other than that I don’t know. Doesn’t really matter ether couse I will drive SAAB forever.

Robin
Guest
Robin
5 years 8 months ago

Most likely is that my next car will be a NG Saab 9-5 SW.

But I would also consider a V*lv* or an Audi because they’re some very fine cars as well.
BMW or Merc I would not consider. The first is too sporty (from an image point of view) for me; what works against the latter is that I have not yet the beer-belly that fits between the seat and the steering wheel….

Doctor Donk
Guest
Doctor Donk
5 years 8 months ago

None, but if i have to – i pick BMW 7e or Merc GL most likely (looks ugly but should be nice to drive both road and offroad).

Yerrun
Guest
Yerrun
5 years 8 months ago
In case that buying a Saab was strictly prohibited: I would probably go with a small Audi or Volvo or midsize Peugeot. Or Seat Leon, just because I really like the car, nothing to do with the brand. When I am a bit wiser -read Wealthier- I think Audi/Jaguar. But regarding Mercedes, I can say that my parents considered a C-class before our Saab and the reason for not buying one was that Belgium is full of Mercedes and they wanted something “different”. Sounds like a classic Saab-story, right? For Belgium, it makes PERFECT sense to compare Saab and Mercedes… Read more »
50 % SAAB
Guest
50 % SAAB
5 years 8 months ago

I have a 50 % SAAB = SeAt. I can take you all out of the illusion that this should represent the sporty and emotional branch of VW cooperation. It is sort of between two SAAB’s and will be exchanged as soon as the 9-3NG comes out. This is one of the most soul-less cars I ever have driven, so I can not recommend it along the SAAB.

eadams
Guest
eadams
5 years 8 months ago

Jaguar … because of its history (fan of William Lyons, Bill Heynes, Norman Dewis, etc) and the fact they are making some very nice cars at the moment. I also appreciate that the cars are made in a factory in Castle Bromwich which during WWII made the Supermarine Spitfires that saved the world from the Nazis.

Lonnie
Guest
Lonnie
5 years 8 months ago
I second the Porsche / Alfa fascination. I tried the Audi thing back before they were the #1 choice of “cocks” (Clarkson reference). Nice cars but way too austere. Rock soilid but no soul. My very first car was a Subaru GL. I still have a soft spot for those things but I’m not seventeen anymore. My 9-5 is the best car I’ve ever had. I love it as much as one can love a car without being concidered bizarre. A Mercedes may hold more value, a Toyota may be more practical, a BMW may make my neighbors more jealous… Read more »
Allan
Guest
Allan
5 years 8 months ago

My non-SAAB toy is an Aston Martin DB9. However, much like you the only real choice for me is SAAB! I bought the DB9 for all the wrong reasons, namely speed. That car mainly just sits. My true driving pleasure is the SAAB.

bk-aero
Guest
bk-aero
5 years 8 months ago

A man of excellent taste! 😉

GerritN
Guest
GerritN
5 years 8 months ago

“I bought the DB9 for all the wrong reasons, namely speed”

We feel your pain!

Oscar, from Barcelona
Guest
5 years 8 months ago
For my the comparison makes sense bearing in mind that it is the opinion of a journalist, not ours. In fact, after reading both comments, anyone can draw his own conclusions: I would buy the Saab because “it is a great value for the money”, and I like best the external shape and also the interior. Talking about others cars, apart from the Saab 900 NG, I have a MB SLK MkI and I am most satisfied with it. I would say it is also a “quirky” car that set a trend (coupe and convertible in one) when it was… Read more »
Marque
Guest
Marque
5 years 8 months ago
Audi is the paradise for the people that is unsure of himself and wants “the high level car that anyone has”. Thanks for this definition, one couldn’t have put it better! I also used to have a boss a couple of years ago – he was living in Barcelona – and he always quoted “Audi? It’s the cheapcar here”. (He had a Subaru WRX back then, btw.) I don’t know how much right he had in saying that, nonetheless I wasn’t surprised at all. Audi for me is the worst of all. Has a completely meaningless “image” and equally, a… Read more »
Alexandros
Guest
Alexandros
5 years 8 months ago

A few days ago my wife and I drove in our ’07 9-3 convertible next to a BMW 335i Convertible.

I ‘ve asked my wife, if she could imagine us in this car. We both said: ” NO WAY!”. I know, we would say the same for Audi, Mercedes, Opel etc…

So, as long a Saab is alive, first choise will be Saab…

Second choises:
Alfa Romeo (159 Sportswagon)
Land Rover Defender

saabdude
Guest
saabdude
5 years 8 months ago
When I couldn’t lease another SAAB in December of 2009, I looked at quite a few brands, and ultimately chose an Audi A5 coupe. My two MOST important criteria are that the car HAS to have a manual transmission, and the color HAS to be black. From there…it’s all “icing on the cake”. After that, the car has to be fun to drive, i.e. it MUST have excellent handling, have good performance (doesn’t have to set any land speed records), not look like every other car on the road, and get 28+ mpg on the highway. Finally, I wanted an… Read more »
Andreas Rydin
Guest
Andreas Rydin
5 years 8 months ago

Only SAAB for me!

But if SAAB hadn´t been born, I Would say:
1, Porsche
2, Alfa Romeo

mike900
Guest
mike900
5 years 8 months ago

Volvo C30 with all the sporty goodies and body kit included

That will be the Viggen replacement if the next Saab hatch 9-3 or 9-2 variant doesn’t end up being any good…. which is impossible right?

Bring back the hatch!!!!

Tompa
Guest
Tompa
5 years 8 months ago

Aah, the C30. Not realy a hatch like a Saab hatch and with the ugliest taillights in the world.
The C30, by my moms husband called the uggliest, most plasticy car car you can get besides a Trabi for the price of a BMW

Andy Rupert
Guest
5 years 8 months ago

On my day off last week, I followed a white C30 that was purchased from our dealership. I’ve always liked the C30 (fun to drive, cool design, etc.) but I have to agree that the tail lights look funny from the rear. The way they light up is a bit different than expected.

mike900
Guest
mike900
5 years 8 months ago

Yeah… I guess I kind of like the fact that the c30 is a little bit odd. The rear end is certainly a bit ugly…. which for some reason makes me like it even more 🙂

I just like the combination of the sporty body kit, Swedish, hatch, 2.5 turbo….. I just can’t help thinking of it as Ovlovs attempt at a Viggen.

Funky little car –

saab93f
Guest
saab93f
5 years 8 months ago

OTOH it is quite understandable that the other swedish might attract Saabistis but to me it is nothing but WRONG. I had to allow myself thinking about the options a year ago (who can guess why?) and I could see me in Merc or even in Audi or Beemer but never ever in a Ovlov. It is curious since they are generally good cars but to me just as much an alternative as a Lada (a russian crappy car based on Fiat 124 for those who don´t know).
That´ll never change – me and Volvo are not a pair.

Paddan
Guest
Paddan
5 years 8 months ago
We own a 2006 MB E 350 4matic wagon along with my 2009 9-3 Aero XWD SC. They are even the same color combination. The MB is buttery smooth and relaxed. We bought it used 3 years ago. It has had lots of things break on it and is not as much fun to drive as the 9-3, of course. My wife loves it, though. I still like those gas sucking Land Rover LR4s (the MB replaced a LR3) and Rangies and also own a 1973 NAS Series III. So would seriously consider a Landie. But only if Saab was… Read more »
Jeff
Guest
Jeff
5 years 8 months ago
I think we’re all just tied to the Saab religion on this blog, so I don’t think this crowd is going to give you the ideal response you’re looking for. For me it’s a Saab or nothing, but I do still get excited seeing what Jaguar/Land Rover are doing. The CLS mercedes is something when I see it I could imagine myself wanting if the 9-5 didn’t exist. Fortunately we don’t have to go through that wrenching rediscovery process we thought we might have to when Saab was in jeopardy last year at this time. You know what’s interesting is… Read more »
saabdude
Guest
saabdude
5 years 8 months ago
“How many sales does Saab lose because people are 3/4 of the way sold but hold back because of some really stupid superficial issues that could be quashed with an effective marketing campaign? I wonder.” In the US? Trust me…a LOT. Hopefully, with fewer GM types at SCNA…and more people who really CARE about SAAB…things will change for the better. They sure need to do something ASAP. I was a SAAB Sales/General Manager back in SAAB’s good days of the late 1980s & early 1990s. I had many customers come in who had never driven a SAAB, and once I… Read more »
RS
Guest
RS
5 years 8 months ago

You’re both right. Improved customer service and an excellent warranty (that the masses know of!) would do wonders. Might push a lot of folks over to Saab as most people know its a good Swedish brand but they don’t want to take any chances.
Well, no risk involved if Trollhättan/SCNA would come out and say “-We’ve got you covered for many years what”.

RS
Guest
RS
5 years 8 months ago

… ever happens”. (sorry was on the phone) 😉

BaRa
Guest
BaRa
5 years 8 months ago

About the architect thing, I never get that. What I do get is “But I thought you were an architect? And now you tell me you’re in marketing?” Sometimes people’s minds are not flexibel at all 🙂

Paddan
Guest
Paddan
5 years 8 months ago
Personal story – back in 1969, my dad looked at the newly introduced 99 and test drove at two local dealers. He owned a ’67 Volvo 144S and liked the safety plus FWD benefit that the Saab had but Volvo did not. One shared the showroom with Dodge and only had three cars in stock. The other was a one car showroom, but exclusively Saab dealer. He didn’t buy the 99 because he said Saab didn’t seem to show growth – instead he traded in on a Volvo 164. He finally bought a Saab when the exclusive dealer expanded –… Read more »
ArneS
Guest
ArneS
5 years 8 months ago

For me it’s only SAAB (own my 13th now, and I have loved them all). If there were no SAAB to buy, I think I would consider a Volvo or a Alfa.

Anders RO
Guest
Anders RO
5 years 8 months ago
The car tests might make sense to the other buyers that have less fanatic preferences… I was to the hairdresser, used to go to a no fancy one where it took 8 minutes to get a hair cut, no reservation needed, but Costel, my former hairdresser, has now retired. My loving and caring wife booked me with a more upscale hair stylist, where it takes over an hour to get a hair cut. During the time he makes sure that every single hair is correctly cut, what you do, small talk. I did not really have any interest into the… Read more »
J Fan
Guest
J Fan
5 years 8 months ago
Swade, how about this reason: Maybe in the USA, maybe in the UK, somewhere there is a guy writing a piece called ‘I want the Merc.’ This fellow might never have considered anything else but a Merc. It doesn’t matter how good or bad the Mercs are, or how good or bad the opposition is: he wants the Merc. Now, one day, this fellow opens up AutoExpress and he reads about the Saab 9-5, a car that is not on his radar – nothing is, of course, because it’s not a Merc. He is shocked at the comparison. He tells… Read more »
Graeme Lambert
Guest
5 years 8 months ago

What he said ^
Seriously though, you hit the nail on the head J Fan.
I’ve been a Saab fanboi for years, and will continue to have a huge soft spot for them for many more i expect. But for every Saab fanboi there’s at least the equivalent amount of BMW fanbois, or Mercedes or Audi fanbois.
Saab NEEDS to convince NEW customers they want a 9-5, not the diehard enthusiasts found on this and other Saab sites.

RS
Guest
RS
5 years 8 months ago

Graeme, what was your impression of the driving ergonomics/comfort? I didn’t see any references in my quick glance through the review.
This is probably the number one reason for us to buy Saabs. Driving characteristics (goes straight on any surface) overall handling (+torque) and reliability probably second and third). Safety fourth…

Graeme Lambert
Guest
5 years 8 months ago
Hi RS. Okay, first of all the Cabin is very comfortable, the electric sports seats very supportive and finished in the premium leather of our test car felt very very nice. There was more side support than in the Mercedes part electric items, though the Saab seats didn’t adjust quite as low as we’d have liked them to. When we previously drove a 9-5 Aero here in the UK it did without the DriveSense package. And honestly, i couldn’t recommend it. I ensured that the car for the twin test had this fitted and it made such a difference. It… Read more »
RS
Guest
RS
5 years 8 months ago

Yes it does and I think you actually nailed it right there. Wish the comments of the Saabs “work environment”, long journey philosophy and better than on paper performance would reach your readers.

BTW what’s your take as a journalsist on a ‘halo’ 9-5?

Graeme Lambert
Guest
5 years 8 months ago
For some reason it won’t let me reply to your post RS, so i’m doing it up here instead. Happy that you agree with my thoughts. As for a halo 9-5? Well if we’re talking A 400bhp Viggen then it sounds great to me as an enthusiast. As a journalist however i’m not so sure. The chassis (at the moment) simply isn’t as capable (in terms of feedback) as some of its current rivals. Market a halo Viggen model and it HAS to offer ultimate driving thrills and feedback, otherwise what’s the point? I think in time there is a… Read more »
Nils
Guest
Nils
5 years 8 months ago
+1. Once upon a time in 1999, (when I had the NG 900), I read a test in the German Auto Motor & Sport between the Saab 9-3 TiD, Rover 75 CDT and Passat TDI. Of course the Passat won the test by points. (VW/Audi always win there.) But the Rover won the comfort part and the Saab came third. I went for a test drive of the Rover 75, very nice car and more refined than the 9-3 at the time. What put me off buying the Rover was the retro dashboard and the lack of a hatch. So… Read more »
Iiari
Guest
Iiari
5 years 8 months ago
Well, I plan to have my 6M Turbo-X SC for a while, since I won’t find that kind of combo in many other makes and love Saab in general. I also can’t can’t follow the crowd and hate passing 30 of the same car I’m driving on the highway… I also can’t go back to the Germans (I’ve had prior BMW’s) after the horrid quality experiences I’ve had (or haven’t had) and I hated the assumptions people thought about me because I drove a BMW. That said, if I were in the mood to cross-shop, I’d probably look at: 1)… Read more »
BaRa
Guest
BaRa
5 years 8 months ago

Mazda MX-5, Alfa Romeo 159, Citroen C6, Jaguar XF, Renault Mégane Coupé. And of course the Superformance Mark III, but that one requires ridiculous sums of money – which I don’t have.

Rune
Guest
Rune
5 years 8 months ago
I do not know what to choose. Audi are doing some things right, but… Nah. But speaking of Mercedes… There is a Saab dealership way up in the north of Norway. I visited their showroom before New Year’s eve, and was surprised to find a MY10 Mercedes E-class in their showroom (a “C220”?). Turns out that someone traded in the Mercedes for a new 9-5. The guy saw a picture of the 9-5, and ordered one without any test drive. That is a decision that makes sense to me. (in case anyone are curious: Our 9-5 is not doing too… Read more »
SteveW
Guest
SteveW
5 years 8 months ago

Rune
The best situation would be the insurance company write it off. Then you get a new car and Saab sell another car! If everyone wiped out their new Saab sales would double – only joking 🙂

Thilo
Guest
5 years 8 months ago

You are wrong, it is an E-class 220 CDI:

http://www.finn.no/finn/car/used/object?finnkode=25296599

Nice car, but not as nice as an Saab 🙂

Phoenix
Guest
Phoenix
5 years 8 months ago

There are of course people that might think of trading their Merc for a Saab but maybe they are few. They like Merc for what the brand stands for and the same goes for many Saab owners. But I think anyway it is an interresting test and many readers might think so as well. And as you say Swade, if you don’t care you don’t need to read it.

Camasi
Guest
Camasi
5 years 8 months ago

Volvo. That new S60 looks nice and is nice to drive.

Belfast_saab
Guest
Belfast_saab
5 years 8 months ago
1. Chrysler 300c (been there, driven that, loved it, would have another) 2. Landrover Discovery – all-round capable motor, perfect family vehicle, too pricey 3. Jaguar XR – lovely coupe 4. Koennigsesgsgsg – you know the one (a tad pricey too!) 5. Audi A5, not A7 though, not keen on the hatch 6. 159 wagon 7. VW Scirocco, not practical, but only good looking VW Not on my list – 1. any M-B, cold clinical and surprisingly plasticky interior 2. A4, A6, Q7, sat in tehm all, all so dull 3. % series – loved the recent one, bored to… Read more »
Paul E
Guest
Paul E
5 years 8 months ago
Four years ago I was seriously considering selling my ’01 9-5 Aero and buying a new E320CDI. The Aero had 150k miles on it at the time, the deal on the Benz would have been fantastic (dealership was getting ready to change hands, car was a demo=$15+k off), and the modern diesel Benz cars are very torquey plus the benefit of improved fuel mileage. After I got home that night, I did more thinking and reading–that generation of E-class was dimensionally identical inside and out to the old 9-5…. and since I’d paid the car note off, I decided I… Read more »
Lars S
Guest
Lars S
5 years 8 months ago

I can’t see myself choosing another car over a Saab, there is just no reason for me to do that. Mercedes-Benz do make some good and beautiful cars, but they are no Saabs and absolutely no Saab-Saabs.

MrMoose
Guest
MrMoose
5 years 8 months ago
I would get Saab: As soon as the future of the company is secured, and new 9-3 is available (and looking good) Audi: I’m actually likely get A4/A5 if it gets a facelift in the autumn. Range Rover: I only they would price the Evoque sensibly. Jaguar: If they come up with X-type replacement I’d definitely be interested! I could consider Alfa Romeo: Would love to but reliability and poor resale values make it a no-go. The new 159-replacement might be however too good to resist… Mini: Would love to get one but they are too small (even the Crossman)… Read more »
Jeff
Guest
Jeff
5 years 8 months ago
My boss at work drives a Cooper S. He’s been driving stick for 23 years and has never had any part of a clutch burn up on him (so he’s not wreaking havoc on clutches). Earlier this year, his clutch went, the dealer put in a new one (but not a new flywheel, because they said it was still fine), and it cost him a ton. Now, his clutch AND flywheel have gone up. The dealer is replacing them for THREE THOUSAND DOLLARS. You know what this says to me? Minis are junk, stay away from them. Thank God I… Read more »
MrMoose
Guest
MrMoose
5 years 8 months ago

Volkswagen: Passat CC is an option. Other than that no-go.

Laurens
Guest
Laurens
5 years 8 months ago

Saab for a long time. Even if it wouldn’t be available from as new factory cars anymore (god forbid), I would look for good occassions, as I did in the past.

However, if all those options would be ruled out eventually, I might have to switch to:
1) Volvo (V70 probably)
2) Audi A4 (Avant)

saabaudi
Guest
saabaudi
5 years 8 months ago
Why so many negative comments against Mercedes E? By Saab´s introduction of the all new 9-5 II the company had not only signaled its comeback but also insisted to play a competitive role in the upper class field of cars like Mercedes E, BMW 5, Audi A6, Nissan Infiniti and so on. Now the motor-magazines are more and more observing the brand again and it`s their job to start comparisons of such cars. What we should see as Saab´s enthusiasts very positively is the 9-5 II is also a part of this game. In my opinion this fact alone is… Read more »
Tompa
Guest
Tompa
5 years 8 months ago

Well it was not my choice, so I´m now owner of a Toyota that my mother bought because of the need for an automatic and the fact that it´s inexpensive and freed from Roadtax for 5 years.

BUT!!! I would never ever buy a Toyota if the money was mine.

Only brands I would even think of looking at besides Saab would be Bimmer and Honda.

Cheers/Tom

DAVID
Guest
DAVID
5 years 8 months ago
I like Subaru with SAAB, not instead of. If there were no SAAB (and in Dallas, we no longer have a new SAAB dealer…) I would probably have an 80’s Mercedes along with my Forester. I had a W123 (300 D) a several years ago and loved it. I am on the fence now as it is coming on 4 years with my 07 9-3 convertible and I am getting the itch to replace it. I do not really want a 3rd current gen. 9-3, trying to wait on the replacement coming in 2012. I do not really have the… Read more »
Stefan
Guest
Stefan
5 years 8 months ago
As it is now I cannot imagine buying another brand. But when the future for Saab was its darkest I thougt about what to choose and it would be any of these: Honda Accord Subaru Legacy Audi A4 (a bit less appealing then the above two actually, I think it is so generic (not to speak of VW Passat)) Logically I guess I would turn to Volvo but there is something about that (typically Swedish) Saab vs Volvo thing I just cannot get over. Alfa is very appealing but I would not buy it for safety reasons. BMW is also… Read more »
StefanH STHLM 93X
Guest
StefanH STHLM 93X
5 years 8 months ago

If the Jets hadn´t given birth to Saab?

Subaru – Had a Leg04 and a Outb07 before the 9-3X. But todays gen doesn´t turn me on.
Alfa Romeo
Volvo
Honda – Accord latest generations. Civic.
Lexus
Mitsubishi – If they get their act together and deliver a proper sedan/combi. Not space ships like the Grandis.

Pierre
Guest
5 years 8 months ago
I don’t know much about Mercedes anymore, their product lines having gotten so confounded. I do know that every time I’ve attended a comparrison ride-and-drive, I’ve naturally had preconceived opinions about which cars I would like and which I wouldn’t. I always walked away from those events surprised that the Mercedes always exceeded my expectation, where the other German marques might have disappointed me some. That said, and I am sadly old enough to be seen in one. The only ones I’ve ever fancied owning were an old G-wagon….the diesel variety with MB tex seats, rubber floors, manual transmissions…..and some… Read more »
eduardo_spain
Guest
eduardo_spain
5 years 8 months ago
As I wrote before, last May i finally received my first 2010 manufactured Saab 93 Vector SC 1.8T Biopower. Since then I believe that I have become one of Spain´s main bioethanol private buyers, feeling sad about my VISA receipts but very happy considering the combination of my only favourite car brand and the fuel I use. Apart from Saab, if GM would have closed the factory, I probably would have chosen a VOLVO S60, just because it is a Swedish car and my father used to drive an old 245 SC for many years. Alternatively I would have possibly… Read more »
wpDiscuz